Gatsby’s Landing at 120 W 44th Street brings a welcome breath of fresh air to the Times Square area, where finding a genuinely good meal can sometimes feel like a treasure hunt. Tucked into the heart of the Theater District, it manages the rare feat of appealing to both discerning locals and visitors seeking a pre-show dinner that rises far above the typical tourist traps.

The menu draws inspiration from Long Island’s North Shore, with seafood taking center stage in dishes that feel both familiar and refined. Their seafood towers are Instagram-worthy without sacrificing quality, featuring the freshest oysters and perfectly poached shrimp. The pasta offerings strike that ideal balance between creative and comforting, with the lobster ravioli emerging as a standout that regulars order time and again.

What really sets Gatsby’s apart in this neighborhood is the atmosphere – sophisticated enough for a business dinner but relaxed enough that you won’t feel out of place in more casual attire. The art deco touches and warm lighting create a space that feels connected to the area’s theatrical heritage without resorting to Broadway kitsch.

The service hits that sweet spot of attentiveness without hovering, and the staff actually knows how to get you out in time for your show without making you feel rushed. In an area dominated by chains and tourist magnets, Gatsby’s Landing delivers a genuinely enjoyable dining experience that feels like a real New York find.